| Date | Location | Result | |
| Nov 14, 2009 | Wheaton, Ill. | Carthage 35, Wheaton (Ill.) 30 | Box score |
| Nov 7, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 55, North Park 24 | Box score |
| Oct 31, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 41, Millikin 28 | Box score |
| Oct 24, 2009 | Rock Island, Ill. | Augustana (Ill.) 42, Carthage 20 | Box score |
| Oct 17, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | North Central (Ill.) 63, Carthage 48 | Box score |
| Oct 10, 2009 | Elmhurst, Ill. | Carthage 45, Elmhurst 38 | Box score |
| Oct 3, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Illinois Wesleyan 42, Carthage 16 | Box score |
| Sep 26, 2009 | Valparaiso, Ind. | Carthage 34, Valparaiso 24 | Box score |
| Sep 19, 2009 | Kenosha, Wis. | Carthage 50, Lakeland 34 | Box score |
| Sep 12, 2009 | Holland, Mich. | Carthage 26, Hope 19 | Box score |